Theory uncertain fate of the principle of legality of criminal And judicial applications
Abstract
The criminal cases in which it is difficult or impossible to identify the perpetrator of criminal behavior the criminal result of whose conduct is directly connected to causal relation, or that in which it is impossible to distinguish the doer from the partner (under the legislations that differentiate the penalty between them) as well as the cases in which a foreign factor interferes with the behavior of the offender in creating of the criminal result , shall make the court to dubious about them and shall, when there is legal adaptation, make it restricted in building its judgments on a solid basis and excluding what is dubious through investigating what is certainly committed, namely the destiny inhering in those having consent or participated in these cases . Here, the punishment of attempt rather than the punishment of complete crime and the punishment of partner rather than the punishment of the doer are imposed which is relevant to the principles of penal legality , a case which requires a legislative intervention as shown throughout. .
References
- Ibrahim Mustafa, Ahmed Hassan El Zayat, Hamed Abdelkader and Mohamed Ali Elnaggar: Dictionary of the Mediator, Arabic Language Complex, C2, Islamic Library, Istanbul, without a year printed.2. Ibn Manzoor: The Arab Sanctuary, C5, The House of Revival of Arab Heritage, Beirut, Lebanon, without a printed year.3. The Shawkiani: Neal Al-Awtar, Explanation of the Ultimate News from the Sayings of the Master of the Good, Book of Quit and Judgments, C 7, Halabi Press, Egypt, 1953.4. Louis Maalouf: Upholstered in the Language, The Catholic Press Beirut, Lebanon, 1956.5. Nadim and Usama Maraashli, Sahah in Language and Science, C2, Intermediate Dictionary, Renewal of Sahah al-Jawhari, Arab Civilization House, Beirut, Lebanon, 1975.
- Dictionaries and Islamic books:
- Laws:1. Italian Penal Code of 1889.2. The Egyptian Penal Code No. 58 of 1937.3. The Syrian Penal Code No. 148 of 1949.4. The Jordanian Penal Code No. 16 of 1960.5. Iraqi Penal Code No. 111 of 1969.6. The Law of Punishing the Offenders of Escaping Abroad during Military Service No. 28 of 1972.7. Military Penal Code No. 19 of 2007.
- Letters and university papers:1. Talal Abdul Hussein: Criminal Jurisdiction (Comparative Study), PhD thesis, Faculty of Law, Mosul University, 2002.2. Muhammad Madi Jabr: The Rule of Destiny in Legislation, Jurisprudence and Criminal Justice, Master Thesis, Faculty of Law, University of Baghdad, 1991.
- Periodicals:1. Judgments of the Egyptian Court of Cassation, Q5, Q8, Q 17.2. Court of Cassation, Volume IV, Government Press, Baghdad, 1970.3. Journal of Legal Judgments, p. 2, 7, Dar al-Qadisiya Press, Baghdad, 1977.4. Egyptian Law Journal, Q 11.5. Set of Judgments of the Court of Cassation, S5, No. 145, S8, No. 69, X17, No. 19.6. Set of Legal Rules - Judgments of the Egyptian Court of Cassation, C3, C4.7. The Legal Encyclopedia, No. 81, Al-Zaman Press, Baghdad, 2001.8. Encyclopedia of the Judiciary and jurisprudence of the Arab States, c.