الديمقراطية التوافقية وتاثيرها في تعزيز الاندماج المجتمعي في بلجيكا

Section: Articles
Published
Dec 1, 2025
Pages
266-290

Abstract

Can say the concept of consociation democracy has, for decades, proven important as a model for addressing the problems of societies marked by deep plurality, division, and weak social integration. In Belgium, social and cultural structures, especially linguistic differences, drove the adoption of this model to preserve state unity. Political parties reinforced this orientation when they shifted from broad national representation to narrower regional bases.


Social integration is the core of any modern democratic experience, reflecting the ability of linguistic, cultural, and religious groups to coexist within a national framework founded on equality and mutual recognition. Belgium’s state-building process raised many dilemmas, with societal pluralism emerging as a decisive factor shaping political institutions. Repeated tensions among the country’s components produced instability, revealing the limits of a simple unitary state. This failure to achieve integration compelled Belgium to adopt a federal (consociational) structure to avoid collapse amid Flemish demands for independence and Walloon aspirations to join France, with which they share common origins, history, and language.


Yet Belgium’s consociational model has not been free of challenges. Government formation often drags on for months, reflecting elite bargaining rather than genuine popular will. The system has become captive to political elites, while institutional recognition of linguistic identities has reinforced societal divisions and weakened a shared national identity. Thus, while consociationalism preserved the state and prevented disintegration, it simultaneously entrenched fragmentation, making democracy dependent on elite consensus rather than broad social cohesion.

References

  1. A. V. (2025, August 12). The Challenges and the Nature of Consociationalism in the 20th and 21st Centuries: The Case of Universidade Católica Portuguesa. Retrieved from https://repositorio.ucp.pt/bitstreams/87082a05-f104-4378-bd8c-5f9b234591cc/downlo
  2. F. D. (2025, August 15). The Constitution, the Parliament, and the Concerted Decision Processes: Observations Based on the Belgian Experience. Retrieved from https://www.undp.org/sites/g/files/zskgke32
  3. Van Haute, W. E. (2019). Do Characteristics of Consociational Democracies Still Apply to Belgian Parties? Politics of the Low Countries, 1(1). Vancouver.
  4. Wickman, S. B. (1984). Belgium: A Country Study. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data.
  5. Ibn Manzur. (1999). Lisan al-Arab. Beirut: Dar Ihya’ al-Turath al-Arabi.
  6. Arend Lijphart. (2006). Consociational Democracy in a Plural Society (Vol. 1). (Translated by Husni Zeinah). Baghdad: Institute for Strategic Studies.
  7. Osama Abd Ali Khalaf. (2018). Consociational Democracy and the Role of Elites in Institutionalizing Political Divisions. Al-Ustadh Journal, Issue 224, pp. 267–268.
  8. Asmaa Nasreddin & Is'af Ahmed. (2019). A Sociological Approach to the Concept of Social Integration (Durkheim, Parsons, Habermas). Aleppo University Research Journal, Issue 131, pp. 41–44.
  9. Wikipedia (2025, July 23). The Belgian Political Crisis of 2007–2011. Retrieved August 10, 2025, from https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/.
  10. Elham Nasser. (2022, November 1). Consociational Democracy. Retrieved October 7, 2025, from https://political-encyclopedia.org/dictionary/.
  11. Elias Saadeh. (2023). A Comparative Study of Consociational Democracy in Lebanon and Belgium. Unpublished Master’s Thesis. Lebanese University: Faculty of Law and Political Science.
  12. Elias Saadeh. (2023). Previously Cited Source, pp. 50–51.
  13. Bushra Berto. (2005, August 22). Federalism in the New Belgian Constitution in Connection with the Iraqi Constitution Debate. Al-Hiwar Al-Mutamaddin. Retrieved August 10, 2025, from https://www.ahewar.org/debat/show.art.asp?aid=43689
  14. Bouhenia Kouai & Haidar Haj Bashir. (2012). Managing Ethnolinguistic Diversity in Belgium: A Reading of the Experience. African Journal of Political Science, 1(1), p. 49.
  15. Bouziane Radhiya. (2018). Social Integration of Youth in Arab Society: Mechanisms and Requirements. Anthropology Journal, 4(7), pp. 177–178.
  16. Baidar Al-Tall. (2017). The Relationship Between Democracy and Economic Development: A Study of South Korea and Taiwan. Al-Quds Open University Journal, 41(1), p. 92.
  17. Tawfiq Bouqaada. (2016). Consociational Democracy and Its Dimensions. Dafter al-Buhooth al-Ilmiyya, Issue 8, p. 106.
  18. Hafidh Ibrahim & Majid Mahi. (2019). Official Political Institutions and the Party System in Belgium. University of Babylon Journal of Human Sciences, 3(27), p. 289.
  19. Hassan Turki Umeir. (2013). Problems of Democratic Transition in Iraq: A Study in Consociational Democracy. Diyala Journal, Issue 58, pp. 145–146.
  20. Haidar Al-Haidar. (2016). The Constitutional Organization of Consociational Democracy in Pluralistic Societies: A Comparative Study. Al-Muhaqiq Al-Hilli Journal of Legal and Political Science, 3(8), p. 476.
  21. Haidar Al-Haidar. (2016). Previously Cited Source, p. 478.
  22. Haidar Al-Haidar. (2016). Previously Cited Source, p. 483.
  23. Haidar Abd Jassas. (2021). The Reality of Consociational Democracy in Belgium: Lessons Learned. Hammurabi Journal for Studies, Issue 40, p. 258.
  24. Haidar Abd Jassas. (2021). Previously Cited Source, p. 266.
  25. Constitution of Belgium. (2018). Previously Cited Source, pp. 4–5.
  26. Constitution of Belgium. (2018). The Belgian Constitution of 1831 Including Amendments up to 2014. Belgium: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, p. 4.
  27. Rachid Saad. (2019). Consociational Democracy in Plural Societies: A Comparative Study Between Lebanon and Malaysia. Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, 10(1), p. 1734.
  28. Rachid Saad. (2019). Previously Cited Source, p. 1736.
  29. Rachid Saad. (2019). Previously Cited Source, p. 1736.
  30. Raghid Al-Solh. (2007). Consociational Democracy in Its Global and Lebanese Context. Beirut: General Directorate for Studies and Information, UNDP Parliamentary Program.
  31. Rana Mouloud. (2016). The Belgian Federal Political System and Its Role in Achieving Political and Social Stability. University of Anbar Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, Issue 6, p. 11.
  32. Rana Mouloud. (2016). Previously Cited Source, p. 25.
  33. Ronald L. Watts. (2006). Federal Systems. (Translated by Ghali Barhouma). Canada: Forum of Federations.
  34. Saad Shihab Ahmed. (2022). Consociational Democracy and Its Impact on Political Performance in Iraq after 2005 (1st edition). Berlin: Arab Democratic Center.
  35. Suleiman bin Ahmed bin Ayyub. (1994). Al-Mu‘jam al-Kabir (2nd edition). Cairo: Ibn Taymiyyah Library.
  36. Shakir Al-Anbari. (2007). Consociational Democracy: Its Concept and Models (Vol. 1). Baghdad: Institute of Strategic Studies.
  37. Sherzad Ahmed Al-Najjar & Nasreen Ali Arab. (2021). Previously Cited Source, p. 115.
  38. Sherzad Ahmed Al-Najjar & Nasreen Ali Arab. (2021). Problems of State-Building in Plural Societies: The Case of Belgium. Academic Journal of Nawroz University, Issue 10, p. 106.
  39. Shane Keller. (2005). The Right of National Minorities to Veto: Macedonia, Northern Ireland, and Belgium. Adala Electronic Journal, Issue 13, p. 10.
  40. Abd al-Salam Abd al-Allaoui. (2021). Theories of Social Integration. Algeria: Djilali Bounaama University.
  41. Abd al-Salam Abd al-Allaoui. (2021). Previously Cited Source, pp. 23–24.
  42. Abdulkarim Qais Abdulkarim. (2024). Political Leaderships and Their Impact on Consociational Democracy: Malaysia as a Model. Journal of Law and Political Science, University of Iraq, 23, p. 411.
  43. Abeer Mohammed Abd. (2023). Ethnofederalism: A Study of the Belgian Experience. Iraqi Journal of Political Science, Issue 8, p. 285.
  44. Othman Sahban. (2023). Participation and Trust: The Role of Citizen Participation in Enhancing Parliamentary Trust in Morocco. Ma‘rifa Journal, Issue 11, p. 723.
  45. Ali Zaid. (2011). Participation and Social Integration: Theoretical Foundations and Practical Procedures. Annals of Literature and Social Sciences, Issue 32, p. 21.
  46. Ali Zaid Al-Zaabi. (2013). The Crisis of Participation and Social Integration in Arab Countries. Journal of Human and Social Sciences, 12(5), p. 20.
  47. Ali Sufyan. (2022). The Role of Political Consensus in Building Governance Systems: Lebanon and Iraq as Models. Tikrit Journal of Political Sciences, Issue 27, pp. 240–241.
  48. Ali Mohammed Ajeel & Mustafa Mahmoud Jalal. (2024). The Impact of Consociational Democracy on Public Policy-Making in Iraq. Journal of Political Science and Law, Issue 40, pp. 20–21.
  49. Omar Kaiboush. (n.d.). The Role of Consociational Democracy in Managing Political Processes in Sectarian Societies: Malaysia and Lebanon (previously cited), p. 32.
  50. Omar Kaiboush. (2017). The Dialectic of the Relationship Between Consociational Democracy and Achieving Political Stability in Plural States: Mechanisms and Actors (Malaysia as a Model). Journal of Legal and Political Science Research, Issue 6, p. 549.
  51. Omar Kaiboush. (2019). The Role of Consociational Democracy in Managing Political Processes in Sectarian Societies (Malaysia and Lebanon 1989–2015). Unpublished Master’s Thesis. University of Algiers: Faculty of Political Science and International Relations.
  52. Omar Kaiboush. (n.d.). The Role of Consociational Democracy in Managing Political Processes in Sectarian Societies: Case of Malaysia and Lebanon.
  53. Iyad Mohammed Sameer. (2013). Consociational Democracy. Hikma Journal for Philosophical Studies, Issue 1, p. 268.
  54. Ghufran Younis Hadi. (2022). The Political System in Belgium and Secessionist Movements. Iraqi Journal of Political Science, Issue 7, p. 458.
  55. Firas Abdulkarim Mohammed. (2008). Political Systems of the Benelux Countries (Belgium, Netherlands, Luxembourg). Unpublished Master’s Thesis. University of Baghdad: Faculty of Political Science.
  56. Fawzi Boukhris. (2021, September 13). Social Integration and Democracy: Toward a Sociological Approach. Mominoun Without Borders. Retrieved July 1, 2025.
  57. Fouchan Abdulqader & Al-Alawi Ahmed. (2017). Social Integration: Concept, Dimensions, Indicators. Algeria: University of Oran.
  58. Marwan Duwairi. (2010). Consociational Democracy and the Jewish State. Omran Journal, Issue 25, p. 10.
  59. Language Conflicts Encyclopedia. (2020, June 10). Walloon and Flemish in Belgium. Retrieved September 6, 2025, from https://www.languageconflict.org/conflict/walloon-and-flemish-in-belgium/
  60. Melody Adel. (2024). Social Integration: A Multidimensional Sociological Concept. Hikma Journal for Social Studies, Issue 2, pp. 9–10.
  61. Nadia Saeed. (2009). The Arts of Voluntary Work (Vol. 2). Cairo: Qatar Al-Nada Publishing.
  62. Nabhan Salem Marzouq. (2020). Consociational Democracy and Its Implications for Managing Ethnic Diversity. Arab Academy in Denmark Journal, Issue 24, p. 6.